PRIMALUNA

Stereophile 06/2017

PrimaLuna ProLogue Premium Preamplifier
EQUIPMENT REPORT

Herb Reichert, Stereophile 6/2017 - for the original text, click HERE

 

LINE PREAMPLIFIER
A hi-fi system with too little gain can sound dim or hesitant.

Everyone knows that world-class analog and digital sources are the bedrock of all fine audiophile systems. Everyone also knows that a happy relationship of amplifier, speakers, and room makes audiophiles smirk Aren’t I lucky? Fewer among us are aware that the upper limit of sound quality an audio system can deliver will be established by whichever audio contraption we use to select our sources and adjust their volume.

A hi-fi system with too little gain or an impedance mismatch (especially at the interfaces of the selector switch and volume control) can sound dim or hesitant. A system with too much gain can sound jumpy, noisy, or unsubtle. In contrast, when our world-class sources feed a stable, non-fluctuating, high-impedance load, and the control unit’s output is low enough in impedance and high enough in gain to stimulate the power amplifier to its full dynamic effect—then the system will sound as good as it can sound.

In my 100 years of life I have experimented with every possible preamplifier/control device: passive, active, digital, analog, tube, and solid-state. In the end, I usually prefer the liquid transparency and full-color jump factor of a wellengineered, tubed line stage.

You see, preamps don’t have just their own sound—they affect the performance of everything that precedes and follows them.
Nowadays, I anchor my Bed-Stuy bunker system around my reference Pass Labs HPA-1 headphone amp and line stage ($3500), or the fresh transparency of one of these tubed preamps: Linear Tube Audio’s microZOTL2.0 ($1100), the over-achieving Rogue Audio RP-1 ($1699), or the PrimaLuna ProLogue Premium ($2199). The Pass HPA- 1 is the near-perfect rock star of the bunch, but of the three other preamps, the PrimaLuna ProLogue Premium delivers the most jump factor, seductive liquidity, and instrumental color. Which is why I must tell you about it.

PrimaLuna ProLogue Premium Preamplifier

Description

The PrimaLuna ProLogue Premium is basically an oldschool, line-level tubed preamp, created in the Netherlands by Herman van den Dungen, and built in China to levels of quiet, durability, and sonic sophistication not possible in the 20th century.

The ProLogue Premium is built into the same type of blue-gray, subtle metal-flake, lacquer-on-steel case as the ProLogue Premium EL34 tubed power amplifier, which I reviewed in the November 2016 issue.1 That stereo amp weighs 46.3 lbs; surprisingly, this preamp weighs almost as much: 37.5 lbs. It’s so heavy because it has two large, potted toroidal power transformers and two power-supply filter chokes, all sitting atop the chassis, hidden inside a vented box. Including its tube cage, the ProLogue measures 14.5" wide by 8" high by 15.5" deep.

The ProLogue Premium’s dual-mono heavy-duty-ness is enhanced by the use of one GZ34/5AR4 rectifier tube per channel. This design choice is extremely unusual—most tube amps forgo tube rectifiers, instead using solid-state diodes to save space and cost. In their defense, the amp manufacturers often say that solid-state rectifiers are quieter (they’re not), or that they sound better (which I question), or that they do it to make their gear sound less like tubes and more like transistors (which is possible).

When a preamplifier does have a tube rectifier, it’s usually a miniature 12X4 or 6X4 tube rated to draw 90 milliamperes of current—not the indestructible and organic-sounding, octal-base GZ34/5AR4, rated at 250mA. Each of the ProLogue Premium’s 12AU7 twin-triode tubes draws only 20mA, so you can be sure that PrimaLuna is not using massively overspecced and costly octal tube rectifiers for durability alone—no way. I can assure you that PrimaLuna is using one high-current rectifier per channel because Herman van den Dungen believes it makes his $2199 preamp sound richer, faster, and less mechanical than other preamplifiers employing bevies of $1 rectifiers. Why else?

When I removed the ProLogue Premium’s bottom plate, I was instantly impressed by the quality of parts and labor I saw. I’ve serviced countless tube amps, including some of the world’s most expensive, and have never seen bettercrafted point-to-point wiring or more intelligent layout. On their website, PrimaLuna makes a big deal about their tube sockets being bolted directly to their steel chassis. This is because it is a big deal—it makes their products more durable and trouble free than those of competitors who attach tube sockets directly to circuit boards. The latter strategy saves space, labor, and money, but every time the user removes or inserts a tube, there’s a danger of irreparably damaging the board. Over time, that danger becomes a certainty.

Likewise with those volume controls and selector switches I was talking about. Many of the biggest high-end names use a $4 chip, a DS1666 Audio Digital Resistor, as a solid-state potentiometer to control volume; PrimaLuna uses a motorized Blue Velvet potentiometer, made by Alps in Japan, that costs at least ten times as much. Expensive, Japanese-made relays are used for the source-selector switch.
DuRoch polypropylene capacitors are featured in the power supply and signal path, while Solen polypropylene caps, made in France, are used at the outputs. Almost as impressive as all that are the Japanese-made Nichicon storage caps that proudly project from the ProLogue Premium’s chassis top.

On the 7⁄16"-thick aluminum front panel are two symmetrically placed knobs: volume control on the left, input selector on the right. Centrally located between them is a handsome Off/Warming Up/On LED. The On/Off rocker switch is hidden away on the preamp’s left side, just around the protruding edge of the front panel.

On the rear panel is a plethora of gold-plated RCA jacks for the inputs—CD, Tuner, Aux 1, Aux 2, HT (home theater)—and outputs: Tape Out, Out 1, Out 2. There’s also a grounding post. A simple, slender, solid aluminum remote control is included.

The first thing I listen for is a change in the quantity or character of the musical energy.

Listening

Whenever I insert a new preamplifier or source component in the bunker system, the first thing I listen for is a change in the quantity or character of the musical energy projected between the loudspeakers. Is it denser? More textured? Weaker? Does it occupy more or less space in my room? Is it harder or softer? These are important traits to notice.

That in mind, I began my auditions of the PrimaLuna ProLogue Premium with Iggy Pop singing a very stoned, slurry, after-hours take of “Jesus Loves the Stooges” (7" 45rpm EP, Bomp BEP- 114). The song, by James Osterberg and James Williamson, appears to have been recorded with only two poorly positioned microphones: one on Iggy’s upright piano, the other on his thick voice.

I was tracing this strange Iggy moment with a humble Ortofon 2M Black moving-magnet cartridge installed in a Jelco SA750B tonearm mounted an Analogueworks Zero turntable (review to come), driving a Tavish Design Adagio phono preamplifier, and instantly I recognized how the ProLogue Premium enhanced not only the music’s force and strength, but also the space and scale of the sound. Momentum was excellent, and timbres were surprisingly real sounding; but it was the ProLogue Premium’s listen ability that made this crazy-ass recording so enjoyable. With my other preamps, “Jesus Loves the Stooges” sounds more ragged and fuzzy—more as if it’s coming out of a boom box. With the PrimaLuna, it sounded all sweaty and solid, like Iggy onstage.

But as much as I love them, Stooges records are not always good for checking tonal beauty, imaging, or fundamental realisms. So I upped the beauty quotient a little and played Bela Bartok’s Piano Concerto 1, in the 1977 recording by Maurizio Pollini with Claudio Abbado conducting the Chicago Symphony Orchestra (LP, Deutsche Grammophon 2530 901), on the not-so-humble analog rig of Palmer 2.5 turntable, Audio Origami PU-7 tonearm, and Mighty Cala Sound MCS TNT 15 moving-coil cartridge, with a Parasound Halo JC 3+ phono preamplifier and Bob’s Devices CineMag 1131 step-up transformer. This world-class combo let the ProLogue Premium preamp and power amp strut their high-value stuff. The metal-flake blue team brought this spectacular DGG recording to a very high level of fine detail and lush lucidity.

It let the music sparkle and scintillate at late-night whisper levels.

The PrimaLuna tube combo produced the most mind-grabbing spatial contrasts: big and small, far and near were explicitly portrayed. Instrumental tones, staccato rhythms, and artistic intents were vividly exposed. Pollini plays with uncharacteristically wild attacks, and this system let me lose myself in them. Likewise, Abbado and the CSO explode this fantastic concerto—and the ProLogue Premiums let me savor every fast-moving fragment. (This record played so well with this group of components that it created, for me, an unforgettable moment.)

The next day, I played this LP through this system for one of my measurements-oriented audiophile friends. At the end of the concerto, he looked at me and said, “That’s not an amp!” To my quizzical expression he responded, “That’s a second-harmonic generator!” Sheepishly, I admitted that the sound might be a little rich in even-order harmonics, but then asked him, “What else could sort and display this complex music in such a tactile, spacious, satisfying way?” Timpani were far back but completely fleshed out, still weighty and accurately toned. Piano was front right, solid, and frantic, all in just the right amounts. Wind instruments were anchored, and the preamp exposed the counterpoint of percussion and piano. Rhythms were precise and kept my attention flowing forward. Unlike my visitor, I could not have been more pleased.

I asked Mr. Objectivity how he thought his system would play this giant, rattling Bartok disc. “Terribly!” he mumbled. “But far more accurately!”
To further torture my guest, I put on the Kronos Quartet’s recording of John Adams’s smart, frolicking John’s Book of Alleged Dances (CD, Nonesuch 79465-2). We listened to this fun bit of art music through my Integra DPPS-7.2 DVD-A player (used as a disc transport) and Schiit Audio’s Yggdrasil DAC ($2200). Mr. O cringed as I pulled out the CD. When he spotted the Schiit, he rolled his eyes. But when he recognized the veracity, true tones, and vivid textures of David Harrington and John Sherba’s fiendishly dancing violins, he didn’t cringe and his eyes didn’t roll.
I can speak only for my taste, but I swear: Listening to these Alleged Dances through this trio of real-world components gave me levels of robust joy and musical satisfaction that would be hard to match at several times their price. (I was using the $8400/pair DeVore Fidelity Orangutan O/93 speakers and moderately priced AudioQuest cables and interconnects.)

Late one night, a suave and cultured audio friend, Francois Saint-Gerand of Mighty Cala Sound, turned me on to a ridiculously hip recording from 1969: Comme à la Radio, by France’s most talented avant-garde chanteuse, Brigitte Fontaine (LP, Superior Viaduct SV042). Fontaine (b. 1939) is a novelist, actress, playwright, and poet whose main career has been singing her own art songs and musically collaborating with the likes of Stereolab, Gotan Project, Sonic Youth, Grace Jones, Noir Desir, Archie Shepp, Arno—and, on this album, the Art Ensemble of Chicago and her future husband, Areski Belkacem (b. 1940).

It took only a few seconds of Comme à la Radio for me to realize that Fontaine would become my latest French obsession, following Bardot, Piaf, and Debussy. The way this vivid multi-mono album is constructed puts Fontaine’s voice right up close to her microphone. Likewise Areski’s melodic recitations and accompaniment on sitar and guitar. This is art and music to die for, and the PrimaLuna preamp made each surprising track sound intense and freshly recorded. This album, recorded 48 years ago, sounded so vivid and exposed that I thought I could sense the magnetic tape passing over the recording heads.

Whatever kind of distortion Mr. O thought the PrimaLuna gear was generating, I couldn’t hear any of it. The ProLogue Premium preamplifier let me play this record much louder than I usually would, and still feel relaxed and focused while listening. It also let the music sparkle and scintillate at latenight whisper levels.

PrimaLuna ProLogue Premium Preamplifier

Comparison

After I’d substituted Rogue Audio’s RP-1 tubed preamplifier2 ($1695) for the ProLogue Premium, instrumental tones and piano notes felt abbreviated. Attacks seemed minutely suppressed, and decays were attenuated. Perhaps because of this, the Rogue was more intense in boogie factor, which in turn let beats and rhythms hold my attention longer.

The Rogue’s “shorter” sound made bass feel more taut and muscular—but because of the reduction in harmonics and the attenuation of decays, there seemed to be less of it. Instrumental colors and midrange textures sounded more fully developed through the PrimaLuna. Because of this, the RP-1 was less beautiful in its transparency, and sometimes even noticeably gray. Through the Rogue, details were more finely drawn but seemed to emerge from a drier, shallower space. Conceivably, I’m describing the absence (Rogue) vs the presence (PrimaLuna) of Mr. O’s second-order harmonic distortion.

Overall, the Rogue RP-1 felt more masculine and declarative, always marching and battling its way through difficult music. The RP-1 drove like a ’69 Camaro Z28. In contrast, the PrimaLuna ProLogue Premium drove like a 1962 Alfa Romeo Giulietta Spider. It seemed more feminine and seductive. It danced, laughed uncontrollably, and sang. It guzzled French wine by the bottle, and would, after enough wine, kiss me full on the lips.

Nevertheless . . .

The ProLogue Premium has a high input impedance of 100k ohms and delivers a fixed gain of 12dB, which is just slightly on the low side of normal. I’ve been driving the PrimaLuna preamp just perfectly with Schiit’s Yggdrasil and Mytek’s Brooklyn DACs and a variety of phono stages: the Tavish Design Adagio, Parasound Halo JC 3+, and Lounge Audio LCR Mk.III. Gainwise, no matter which amp or source I connected it to, the ProLogue’s volume control always ended up in that optimal range of 10am–2pm.

Like all tubed preamplifiers without cathode-follower outputs, the ProLogue Premium’s specified output impedance is high: 2800 ohms. This means it will sound its lively, detailed, frequencyextended best only if you connect it to a power amp with an input impedance of greater than 28k ohms. Barring unusual circumstances, a properly quiet and dynamic source-preamp match should not be difficult to achieve.
That accomplished, you should sense a new, nearly invisible, but tangibly luminous presence in every recording you play. Punch and drive should be obvious, but not overly or solid-state aggressive. You’ll notice a feeling of ease and refined forward propulsion. Bass response will feel enjoyably strong, but maybe not as detailed as you’re used to with solid-state amplification. Most of all, you should notice the Pro- Logue Premium’s liquid transparency.

I have experienced many of the best and most expensive preamps, and none has been perfectly invisible. Surprisingly few have been more invisible than the PrimaLuna ProLogue Premium. With its stock tubes, the ProLogue Premium seemed about 80% invisible, with a forecast of 15% sunny and 5% cloudy skies. Humidity was above 50%. The absolute best tubed or solidstate preamps I’ve heard have never been more than 90% invisible—or cost less than $10,000.

In nearly two years of use, the ProLogue’s stock tubes behaved perfectly: 100% dead quiet and grain-free. Exchanging them for new old stock (NOS) tubes from Amperex, RCA, Mullard, Brimar, or Telefunken will be unlikely to add any invisibleness, but they will adjust, in varying subjective amounts, the sonic weather factors mentioned above. NOS valves might also add force, shimmer, or texture to the sound. Although I didn’t experiment with alternate brands of tube, the ProLogue Premium’s chassis-mounted tube sockets clearly indicate that it was designed to accommodate this kind of fun, and PrimaLuna devotes a webpage to the subject: www.primaluna-usa.com/tube-rolling.

In the end

I’ve listened to the PrimaLuna ProLogue Premium preamplifier at great length and carefully studied its construction. I’ve installed the review sample in my system many times and removed it just as often—it’s been banged about. So I can say, without doubt, that it’s built to last and is musically effective. Its combination of beguiling transparency and dynamic authority reproduces complex music and recordings with ease and elan. In even a very expensive system, it will not set limits on musical enjoyment. As I concluded my review of PrimaLuna’s ProLogue Premium power amp: Class A sound at a Class C price.

Links:
www.stereophile.com/content/primaluna-prologue-premium-poweramplifier
www.stereophile.com/content/rogue-audio-rp-1-preamplifier


na górę
© 2003-2014 FAST Łódź. Wszystkie użyte znaki towarowe są zastrzeżone i należą do ich prawnych właścicieli.
powrót na stronę główną na górę
 
PREVIOUS
(left arrow key)
NEXT
(right arrow key)
CLOSE (Esc)